Metagaming

​

Definition: In Dungeons & Dragons (D&D), metagaming refers to the use of knowledge or considerations that are outside of what a character would know or be aware of within the game world. This can include player knowledge of game mechanics, creatures' statistics and abilities, plot information, or other characters' secrets. It is a contentious issue in role-playing games, as it can potentially undermine the immersive role-playing experience and disrupt game balance.

​

Characteristics: Metagaming can take several forms, such as:

​

1. Mechanical Metagaming: Using detailed knowledge of the game rules to influence in-character decisions. An example might be choosing to attack a creature with a certain type of damage because the player knows the creature is vulnerable to it, even though the character has no reason to know this.

2. Narrative Metagaming: Using knowledge about the plot or NPCs that the player has but the character does not. For instance, acting on a plot twist before it has been revealed in-game.

3. Inter-Character Metagaming: Using knowledge about other characters that has not been shared in-game. This can include acting on another character's secret backstory or unspoken plans.

4. Metagaming Ploys: Attempts to manipulate game mechanics for advantage, such as deliberately getting knocked unconscious to remove certain conditions or intentionally provoking opportunity attacks to drain enemies' reactions.

​

Ethical Considerations: The ethics of metagaming in D&D often depend on the social contract of the table:

​

1. Disruption: Metagaming can disrupt the narrative flow, break immersion, and lead to an unfair distribution of spotlight time. Many groups discourage metagaming for these reasons.

2. Collaborative Storytelling: However, in some circumstances, metagaming can aid in collaborative storytelling. Some degree of narrative metagaming can be helpful for party cohesion or to ensure the plot progresses smoothly.

3. Player vs Character Knowledge: It's crucial to distinguish between player knowledge and character knowledge. A seasoned player can have a character with little adventuring experience, and it's part of the player's role to ensure their character acts according to their in-game knowledge and experience.

​

DM Considerations: As a Dungeon Master, it's important to set expectations about metagaming:

​

1. Set Clear Table Rules: Be clear about what degree and types of metagaming are acceptable at your table.

2. Encourage Role-playing Over Roll-playing: Encourage players to make decisions based on their characters' perspectives, experiences, and motivations, not just on what is mechanically advantageous.

3. Handle Disruptions Fairly: If metagaming disrupts the game, address it openly and fairly. Discuss the issue with the group and come up with solutions together.

4. Educate New Players: New players might not understand the distinction between player and character knowledge. Educate them about metagaming and why it can be an issue.

​

Metagaming is a complex issue in D&D with no one-size-fits-all solution. The key is to communicate openly and honestly as a group and to agree on the approach that will provide the most enjoyable experience for everyone.

​

Dealing with Metagaming: A Guide for Dungeon Masters

​

Metagaming, the act of using out-of-character knowledge to influence in-character decisions, can often present a challenge in maintaining immersion and balance in your Dungeons & Dragons games. Here are some strategies to help you manage metagaming as a Dungeon Master.

​

1. Set Clear Expectations: At the beginning of a campaign (or during Session Zero), discuss the issue of metagaming with your players. Define what metagaming is and express your expectations for maintaining the separation between character knowledge and player knowledge. Let your players know that you value role-playing and decision making that is true to their characters.

2. Encourage Role-play: Promote decisions based on character motivations and knowledge rather than player knowledge. Ask players to justify their actions from their character's perspective if you suspect metagaming. "Why would your character think to do that?" can be a good question to prompt a player to think from their character's point of view.

3. Modify Encounters: If players use metagame knowledge to exploit certain creature weaknesses, feel free to modify your creatures. Change a monster's vulnerabilities, resistances, or abilities to keep players on their toes. Remember, your players' characters only know what they've learned in-game. The element of surprise can be a useful tool in preventing metagaming.

4. Use Secret Notes: If a character learns something that the rest of the party doesn't know, consider passing that information through a secret note or a whispered conversation away from the table. This method can help maintain the distinction between character and player knowledge.

5. Foster Trust: Build trust at your table so that players feel comfortable with the outcomes of encounters, regardless of success or failure. Ensure that players understand that challenges, setbacks, and character death are all parts of the game and can lead to interesting storytelling opportunities. If players trust in the fairness of the game and the story, they may feel less compelled to metagame.

6. Reward In-character Decisions: Positive reinforcement can be a powerful tool. Praise or reward players who make decisions based on their character's motivations and knowledge, even when those decisions might not be optimal from a game mechanics standpoint. This might include inspiration points, roleplay experience points, or in-game rewards.

7. Discuss Metagaming Incidents Openly: If you notice metagaming happening during the game, consider addressing it directly. After the session, have a conversation with the group about what happened and why it could be problematic. Use it as a learning opportunity rather than a moment of conflict.

8. Provide In-Game Information: Give your players opportunities to gain knowledge in-game that they may already know as players. This could be through research in a library, talking to a knowledgeable NPC, or through magical divination. This allows players to utilize their knowledge legitimately.

9. Adjust for Different Player Types: Remember that not all players are the same. Some might be more prone to metagaming than others, especially those who are more interested in the tactical or strategic aspects of D&D. Try to provide a balance of encounters and challenges that cater to all types of players.

​

Metagaming can be a tricky issue to navigate, but with open communication and a focus on character-driven role-play, it is possible to minimize its impact on your game. Always remember, the goal of D&D is to have fun and create a memorable, shared storytelling experience.